Should Disney Be Reimagining Haunted Mansion Instead of Splash Mountain?

Haunted Mansion Stretching room with hanging scene and an x on it
Credit: Disney / Canva

WARNING: The following article mentions and/or discusses topics that may be distressing for certain audiences. Viewer discretion is advised.

Disney Parks ever remains on the cutting edge when it comes to the creation of entertainment offerings across the globe, and that cutting-edge standard comes in various forms like attractions, rides, park experiences, and the reimagining of current offerings.

cinderella castle

Credit: Disney

Perhaps one of the most prominent examples of this is the reimagining of the Splash Mountain attraction at Disneyland Resort and the Walt Disney World Resort, which will become a new Princess and the Frog-themed attraction called Tiana’s Bayou Adventure later in 2024.

While fans can appreciate Disney’s dedication to continually upgrading the guest experience at Disney Parks, many feel that The Walt Disney Company picked the wrong attraction with which to start.

Splash Mountain

The first version of Disney ParksSplash Mountain attraction opened to Guests at Disneyland Resort on July 17, 1989.

Exactly three years later, guests at the Walt Disney World Resort in Florida were offered a soft opening of the Splash Mountain attraction, followed by the grand opening of the ride on October 2, 1992, just a day after the attraction opened at Tokyo Disneyland.

Splash Mountain at Magic Kingdom Park

Credit: Disney

Related: Young Boy Jumps Out of Splash Mountain Log Flume, Causing Panic and Mass Evacuation

Disneyland’s version was hailed on the resort’s official website as a “hare-raising experience,” one that invites guests to “hop inside a hollow log and float through a colorful bayou as you follow happy-go-lucky Br’er Rabbit to his “laughing place.” But be warned: Br’er Bear and Br’er Fox are in hot pursuit of this wayward hare.

Glide past over 100 talking, singing, storytelling Audio-Animatronics critters who inhabit Splash Mountain and offer up their own slice of down-home culture. Sing along to classic Disney ditties, including “Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah.”

br're fox br'er bear br'er rabbit splash mountain

Credit: Disney

Related: Disney Removes Beloved Controversial Song From Magic Kingdom Parade, Effective Immediately

A similar description was found on the Disney World website.

Both the Disneyland and Walt Disney World Resort attractions boasted 950,000 gallons of water, three dips, and a finale that consisted of a massive five-story splashdown.

Make Way for Tiana’s Bayou Adventure

But in June 2020, Disney announced a massive reimagining of the attraction via Disney Parks Blog:

“Splash Mountain at both Disneyland Park in California and Magic Kingdom Park in Florida will soon be completely reimagined. The theme is inspired by an all-time favorite animated Disney film, “The Princess and the Frog.”

tiana adventure

Credit: Disney

Related: Splash Mountain Has Been Closed for a Year, and You Should Be Excited

Disney further announced that the ride would “pick up this story after the final kiss and join Princess Tiana and Louis on a musical adventure featuring some of the powerful music from the film as they prepare for their first-ever Mardi Gras performance.”

But little else was known then about plans for the take-two of the famous log flume water ride at Disney World and Disneyland Park.

Controversy and Debate

What was known was that Splash Mountain was based on an old Disney film that has been at the center of controversy and debate in recent years. Because of this, the film isn’t available on DVD or Blu-Ray, and it has never debuted on the Disney+ streaming platform. In fact, it’s just about impossible to find the film–even on sites like eBay and Amazon.

Splash Mountain, like every other Disney Parks attraction, was based on a Disney story–and it tells a story. No harm, no foul, right?

Wrong, according to a growing number of fans who voiced concerns over Disney’s 1946 The Song of the South, upon which the attraction was based. The film has long been problematic, as many feel the film helps to perseverate racist stereotypes against the African American community.

disney's song of the south

Credit: Disney

Related: Should Disney Fans Appreciate or Forget “Song of the South”

The Splash Mountain attraction featured zero references to the film’s main character, Uncle Remus. Rather, it featured only the animal characters from the film, such as Br’er Rabbit, Br’er Bear, and Br’er Fox.

And because the Song of the South film is unavailable, the chances are that many guests who experienced the Splash Mountain attraction had never seen the film and knew very little–if anything–about any potentially offensive elements of the film.

Disney Parks announced that the newly reimagined Splash Mountain attraction, which will be named “Tianas Bayou Adventure,” will debut sometime in 2024. The change was as good as done.

tianas bayou adventure jazz loving alligator louis log ride band animals

Credit: Disney

Related: Disney Retires Controversial 53-Year-Old Disney Character; Opts for Politically Correct Replacement

And while there’s viable merit to Disney’s efforts in combatting potentially harmful and hurtful elements like racial stereotypes in its productions and Disney Parks attractions based upon those productions, there’s at least one potentially harmful and hurtful element in another Magic Kingdom attraction that never should have been included in an attraction–especially in a vacation resort geared toward families.

What About Haunted Mansion?

Among the original team of Walt Disney Imagineers, it was common knowledge that Walt had the long-standing goal of building a “haunted house”-esque attraction at Disneyland.

In fact, the blueprints for the structure that would house such an experience were drawn up, and the structure was built. But because the New York World’s Fair was on the horizon, and Walt had been commissioned by General Electric to produce elements for the company’s pavilion, it was all hands on deck for the World’s Fair efforts.

Disney's Haunted Mansion-Behind the Scenes~ | Disney haunted mansion, Haunted mansion, Haunted mansion disneyland

Credit: Pinterest/Disney

Thus, the stately mansion at Disneyland lay vacant, dormant, empty, and eerily quiet for years before the new Haunted Mansion attraction experience inhabited the house in 1969. When the Walt Disney World Resort opened in October 1971, the Haunted Mansion was among its Opening Day attractions.

Flashback - October 1971

The Haunted Mansion, Disney World, October 1971/Credit: Orlando Magazine

Finally, several years after his death, Walt’s dream had been realized.

Haunted Mansion Suicide Visual

But that dream is often the stuff of nightmares, as the opening scene of the attraction features a visual image of a suicide in the form of a human figure hanging by his neck from the ceiling of the Portrait Chamber (also called the Stretching Room).

It’s distasteful, disheartening, and, quite frankly, disgusting and incredibly disrespectful to anyone whose life has ever been touched by the ripple effects of such a terrible tragedy.

The Haunted Mansion's Stretching Room Returns! - YouTube

Credit: YouTube

Related: Tower of Terror vs. Haunted Mansion: Which is Better?

Because the Haunted Mansion attractions were fashioned after Walt Disney died, the Disney fan inside of this writer unequivocally believes such a scene was no part of Walt’s plan for the new attraction.

Disney had been clear in his directives and instruction to Imagineers that the new attraction would NOT be such an experience, as fans can gather from this 1965 episode of Walt Disney’s Wonderful World of Color.

Related: Walt Disney’s Untimely Death Sparked a Massive Company Cover-Up & Stiff Restrictions For Disney Films

Naysayers have pointed out that the suicide visual is located in the topmost part of the high-pitched ceiling of the Portrait Chamber, so guests can simply look away. But the design of the attraction points Guests’ eyes directly to the suicide element, as all the lights go out, save for those illuminating the hanging figure.

No part of the suicide scene should have ever been included in a Disney Parks attraction, but since there is no such thing as truly re-writing history–despite the efforts taken and edicts passed in recent years in an attempt to do so–this writer will not waste time on the subject of poor judgment on the part of Walt Disney Imagineering in the Haunted Mansion attraction.

Reimagining the Wrong Attraction

Rather, I’ll propose an immediate pause on the Splash Mountain-Princess Tiana project in the name of the far more pressing need for a reimagining that would potentially affect an untold number of guests whose lives have been either grazed or turned upside-down by the tragedy of suicide.

If ever there were an attraction (or element of an attraction) that is harmful or hurtful (not to mention outright heinous) toward guests and Cast Members alike, it’s this visual image inside the Haunted Mansion attraction.

Credit: Becky Burkett, Disney Dining

For the record, it’s also incredibly cold, heartless, and nearly unforgivably insensitive and malicious toward anyone who has ever been affected by suicide. (It’s worth noting that the scene appears in a moment of cliffhanging suspense, offering first-time Guests no knowledge that they are about to see something that could be extremely unsettling for them, making the scene all the more disgusting and disrespectful.)

Who would celebrate such a tragedy? It needs to be removed. Immediately.

Disney would incur extremely minimal costs in this proposed reimagining; after all, it wouldn’t require a complete overhaul. It requires only the removal of the figure and a different lighting sequence (perhaps).

The scene adds nothing to the experience except for a visage of gruesomeness, terror, and personal trauma, each of which would be gone once the image is removed.

13 Interesting Facts About The Haunted Mansion That Will Make You Say, "I Had No Idea"

Credit: Yahoo Sports

Related: Has Disney CONFIRMED This Haunted Mansion Theory?

And during the time it takes for Disney to launch an Imagineer or skilled Cast Member up to the topmost part of the chamber, the situation can be completely rectified by simply keeping all lighting off of the figure above the chamber until it’s removed.

The entire project will prove to be perhaps the most inexpensive and most positive change ever to grace a Disney Parks attraction.

And it needs to be done far sooner than any change to Splash Mountain. This writer is most definitely a Tiana fan, but I’m also a fan of entertainment that doesn’t ostracize any guest on the basis of familiarity with an awful tragedy, and all of my research tells me I’m certainly not alone in this.

If you or someone you know is experiencing suicidal thoughts, please do not hesitate to contact the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline by calling or texting 988 on your phone, or by visiting 988lifeline.org. There will always be someone to answer your call and listen. 

Do you think Disney is reimagining the wrong attraction? Let us know in the comments. 

About Becky Burkett

Becky's from the Lone Star State and has been writing since she was 10 and encountered her first Disney Park when she was 11. It was love at first Main Street Electrical Parade. Joy is blank lined journals, 0.7 mm pens, and all things Walt, Woody and Buzz, PIXAR, Imagineering, Sleeping Beauty (make it blue!), Disney Parks history and EPCOT. At Disney World, you'll find her croonin' with the birdies at the Enchanted Tiki Room or hangin' with Woody and the gang at Toy Story Land. If you can dream, you really can do it!


    • Becky sickens me as well. I will be shocked if she finds anyone to agree with her. What a drama mama.

      • What is wrong with you! Just leave things alone! There was nothing wrong with splash mnt- and people like you ruined that….. now you are going after haunted mansion! You are never satisfied. Shut up and find a different profession. If you don’t like rides at Disneyland- don’t go!

  1. Becky needs to get over herself. No one wants the haunted mansion changed. If you don’t like the ride don’t go on it. I have had friends and relatives die from suicide and I’m not offended or upset by the ride. I don’t think they should have redone Splash Mountain either..I feel the author is a Karen trying to start drama where there is none. Get over yourself Becky.

  2. I think that improvements and changes are always fun and exciting, and gives them the chance to fix structural problems that may have been overlooked. However, I do not think putting one ride of offense over another ride of offense is okay. You are clearly passionate about the issue of suicide, and that is okay we need people like that, but to say it takes over in priority compared to the harm of splash mountain for other groups of people is absurd.

    • Just stop!! Leave the Haunted Mansion alone! It has been this way for decades with no issues! People will always find something in their lives to compare everything to, it is time to grow up! Stop being offended by every single thing in the world!! Just go with it and have a good time!! If you don’t like it, then do not go on it, it’s that simple!

  3. Everyone needs to grow up and not have the whole world baby proofed. Not everyone is going to like everything and it’s not the world’s job to accommodate them. Get a backbone.

  4. I think you’re reading way too deeply into this. While I respect your opinion and recognize the issue of suicide in society, I have never once equated this scene in the ride with the real world. I see no reason to change the scene. If it is too traumatizing, simply don’t ride Haunted Mansion.


    Wow, you-all are right it’s like my dad always said If Not Broke Don’t fix It

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.