Menu

Should Disney Fans Appreciate or Forget ‘Song of the South?’

song of the south uncle remus
Credit: Disney

Song of the South is undoubtedly the most controversial film project ever produced by The Walt Disney Company. The international entertainment juggernaut, standing today as a loud voice in the fight for equality, has done everything it can to scrape the memory of 1946 film from its archives and storied history, going as far as removing what was once the most popular ride at both Disneyland and Walt Disney World.

uncle remus song of the south

Credit: D23

Related: Whoopi Goldberg Wants Disney to Bring Back ‚ÄėSong of the South‚Äô

However, as time turns and Disney faces its past, many hold onto¬†Song of the South, or Splash Mountain for that matter, as not “racist” or simply part of American history that must be told or remembered.

Although that may be true, Disney, as a progressive and forward-thinking company, has included the film and its counterpart log-flume ride in its cleansing scrubbing of its questionable decision-making over the past 100 years.

‘Song of the South’ Disney’s Troubled History

The 1946 film seems harmless enough.

Through¬†Uncle Remus¬†(James Baskett), a young boy (Bobby Driscoll) who now resides in the American South after separating from his parents, learns valuable lessons through stories about¬†Br’er Rabbit. The film, much like¬†Mary Poppins, uses a unique blend of live-action and animation to bring the stories to life.

So, what’s the problem?

br'er rabbit song of the south

Credit: Disney

Besides the cliche overall appearance and mannerisms of Uncle Remus, a black man living in the South, the stories shared regard Br’er Rabbit, a character symbolizing years and years of ingenious slight by enslaved Americans versus their frequently white adversaries.

Many scholars suggest that Br’er Rabbit, in his American representation, portrays witty enslaved people overcoming the adversity caused by their white enslavers.

Song of the South,¬†which relies heavily on African Folklore published by¬†Joel Chandler Harris¬†in the form of stories incorporating “trickster” characters such as Br’er Rabbit, encompasses appropriation and capitalization on one of the worst atrocities committed against human beings in the history of the civilized world.

Many of the stories that Harris adapted to his published work, which later informed Disney’s 1946 film, are rooted in folklore and tradition carried over to the Americas during the slave trade.

Related: Watch Disney‚Äôs Controversial ‚ÄėSong of the South‚Äô With this Service

Although James Baskett would give an amazing performance in the 1946 film based on the writings of Harris since it’s been scrubbed from Disney’s archives, in fact, Disney withdrew the title from sale in December of 2001.

Although insensitive to the depiction of African Americans by asking James Baskett¬†to use speech equivalent to that you’d expect to hear in slave representation,¬†Song of the South¬†also immorally profited from the dark stories of enslaved people for¬†The Walt Disney Company.

Br’er Rabbit at Disney World and Disneyland

Leaving depictions of Uncle Remus aside, Disney decided to take the characters from Song of the South and use them in a once popular attraction for their American-based theme parks.

Opening in 1989 at Disneyland in California and in 1992 at Magic Kingdom in Walt Disney World, Splash Mountain quickly became a fan favorite within Disney Parks.

Splash Mountain Character Makes a Surprise Comeback at Disney

Credit: Disney

Accompanied by fantastic animatronics and fun,¬†memorable tunes¬†such as “Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah,” composed by Allie Wrubel for the 1946 film, Splash Mountain offered amazing scenes combined with a fast-faced plunge, all set to the side-splitting stories of Br’er Rabbit, Br’er Fox, Br’er Bear, and others.

Related: Disney Imagineer Defends ‚ÄėSong of the South‚Äô and Splash Mountain

Although full of laughs and fun, many riders of¬†Splash Mountain have enjoyed the attraction with little to no knowledge of the dark undertones surrounding Br’er Rabbit and company. However, as Disney has grown into a progressive, outspoken champion of human rights, the decision was made to remove the current theming of Splash Mountain, leading to the closure of both attractions on each coast.

Splash Moutain Lives On Thanks To a Hilariously Bad Disney Promotional Video

Credit: Disney/Canva

Since then, work has been underway to retheme the rides, featuring Disney’s only African American princess, Tiana from The Princess and the Frog (2009). Soon-to-be Tiana’s Bayou Adventure, Splash Mountain, has physically been removed from Disney Parks in the United States.

However, it hasn’t left the hearts of many who feel that removing the attraction is an overreaction by Disney as they attempt to remain favorable in the eyes of their audience.

Related: This Disney Park’s Splash Mountain Just Became a Record-Breaking Attraction

Although removing the theme of Splash Mountain from US parks, but not¬†Tokyo Disneyland¬†for some reason, seems like it would help to further distance The Walt Disney Company from its checkered past,¬†Song of the South¬†still remains a talking point for many, some of whom believe the film isn’t at all problematic. Some even still¬†support the movie.¬†

Fans are Divided Over ‘Song of the South’

Interestingly enough, there still is wide debate over Song of the South and Splash Mountain.

Although you’ll find fans of the film and ride in support groups all over social media, even some historians have voiced their distaste¬†for Disney’s decision to erase the existence of the movie and attraction from its own timeline.

song of the south john braskett

Credit: Disney

Disney, in further efforts to remain politically correct, have turned their sights from Uncle Remus to other classic animation projects by adding disclaimers at the beginning of films such as Peter Pan or Dumbo.

Also, the studios of The Walt Disney Company have taken a liking to allowing progressive messaging to be sounded proudly and loudly within their recent string of live-action remakes of beloved Disney classics.

In a world that is struggling between who it wants to be and who it used to be, Disney has decided to move forward from what it clearly considers to be a past full of regrettable mistakes. Some view this as pandering, while others consider it progress.

It leads many of us to consider what to do with Song of the South. How should we view it? 

Uncle Remus Walked so Mary Poppins Could Run

History and controversy aside,¬†Song of the South¬†didn’t just pave the way for Splash Mountain.

It also was a massive step in the right direction for Walt Disney Animation, who would go on to create amazing projects like Mary Poppins in 1964, which utilized the same techniques of combining live-action shots with animation.

Splash Mountain

Credit: Disney Dining

For this reason, Song of the South has earned its place in Disney animation history. However, many hold it regarding rival Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs and its importance to Walt Disney and the future of the company he started. 

Snow White, often considered to be the holy grail of animation, helped lay the foundation for what The Walt Disney Company would become, and although Uncle Remus and Br’er Rabbit played their part in the years that followed, their overall weight in the company is minuscule compared to Disney’s original animated full-length feature film.

Ultimately,¬†Song of the South¬†was a stain into who many believe Walt Disney to be. Released at a time when slavery had been abolished, there’s zero doubt that the animators, writers, actors, and producers who worked on¬†Song of the South¬†were ton-deaf to the bigotry and persecution that African Americans were still enduring, especially in the southern United States.

For this reason, to preserve our idea of Walt Disney, the company, and what’s to come, most feel that it’s best for¬†Song of the South to be left behind and forgotten.

Do you think Song of the South should be forgotten? Let us know in the comments. 

About Michael Arnold

Michael is a father, husband, and an Army Veteran. Michael spends his weekends at Walt Disney World and Universal Orlando checking out new merchandise and food. Michael is a graduate of the University of Alabama and has an education background in Public Health. You can find Michael riding Pirates of the Caribbean over and over again or binge watching new Marvel and Star Wars content. Han shot first. Thor is the strongest Avenger. Roll Tide and Wash Your Hands!

16 comments

  1. Bring the Song of the South movie back. Love Zip-A-Dee-Doo-Dah song and the movie.

  2. I think Disney should go through with bringing Song of the South back. If people don’t want to watch it or get offended, they don’t have to. We can’t forget this movie, it was a big part of Disney and African American history. Brer Rabbit stories helped people back in those days get by. In conclusion, Disney should bring this movie back as well as restoring the Splash Mountain rides back to the Song of the South theme.

  3. I believe we should apprecite it. We can’t sweep the past under the rug.
    Things were different then. We all know it wasn’t right, and didn’t agree with it, but we need to move on to a better future. We just need to educate are children to treat everyone with respect. It was disheartening to see them shut down Spash Mountain, it was one of my favorite rides in all of Walt Disney World. That was one of the rides that I always looked forward to. When you left the ride, you left in a happy and whimsical mood. It even had you humming or whistling Zip-A Dee-Doo-Dah afterwards.
    Wish they would bring it back! All of my children and grandchildren are upset that it is gone as well.

  4. Song of the South should definitely be revived. It’s a great movie and the stories are an imptortant park of African American Culture.

  5. I truly believe it should be brought back. It is as if people are dishonoring James Baskett who played a wonderful, kind and smart Uncle Remus. He would probably be brokenhearted if he were around today. And I believe children, and adults alike, should see kindness and compassion in adults, instead of what’s being shown to children these days. Please bring it back!!!

  6. Definitely keep it. The few that are offended buy it Are the same few that are offended by Bugs Bunny, Heckl and Jekyll, the old hobo Kelly show and on and on. There is no reason for them to be offended by this. There are many many more people that believe It is very appropriate and we should continue It. I do not understand why Disney bends a knee to the few and slaps the majority of people in the face.

  7. I remember when Song of the South played in theaters, ya I’m old, but for me “Zip-A-Dee-Doo-Dah Zipp-A-Dee-A, my oh my what a wonderful day” Just means Disney and great family times over many decades. When I walk down main street that is the song in my head. The new crowd with nothing better to do than cancel everything is not going to change my mind. I hope they do not show up with torches and pitchforks at the DisneyDining office for you daring to put this content out there.

  8. Song of the South represents the collective wisdom of black Americans who learned how to pass generational lessons dispite being an enslaved people. The Uncle Remus stories and SotS represent black American family culture and spirit refusing to be held back by adversity. The suppression of that cultural history is denying a large part of Black American heritage that should be taken in pride. The replacement of the those values for a mentality of learned helplessness has been more damaging than even slavery itself was. How much better off would we all be if we remembered and learned from our past instead of trying to forget it because someone might be offended?

  9. I HAVE SEEN THE MOVIE AND OWN A COPY. I THINK THE MOVIE REPRESENTS THE WAYS THINGS WERE. HISTORY NEEDS THE TRUTHS OF THE PAST.

  10. I don’t get it. A film about the friendship between a black man and a white boy is racist, but a movie where the only white member of the cast is told that he shouldn’t speak isn’t.

  11. Absolutely been my favorite movie since I watched it when I was about 12 years old! As I grew older and made my own decisions about lessons during the movie I still love it at 60 years old. What I’m getting sick and tired of is companies that bend to the groups causing trouble thinking that by taking down statues, changing street names, changing school mascots will change history. What happened, happened, NOTHING will change that or the outcome of the actions from that whatever the situation was. Learning and not repeating is what needs to be the focus. Boohoo is my answer to all these people crying over “white did this; black did this; yellow; red; green” get off it people! Just love and befriend anyone with any color skin and get over the “***did this” and “***did that” focus on yourself and what happiness you want and stop living in someone else’s anger wake.

  12. Historical denial is a practice of some pretty sinister cultures. Restore the film and celebrate what it can teach us. Academy Award winning James Baskett and Hattie McDaniel had no problems with it. Clearly, Disney progressives fail to embrace the wisdom of Uncle Remus, “You can’t run away from trouble. There ain’t no place that far.”

    • Colleen Cvitanovich

      I loved Song of the South. I looked on Uncle Remus as a grandfather figure and his stories as fables. Just like Aesop’s fables they taught life lessons.

  13. “Song of the South” should DEFINITELY be “revived” — it’s a great movie with a great cast!!! Anyone that has issues with it doesn’t have to watch it. Unfortunately, I’d be willing to bet that the vast majority of individuals that DO HAVE ISSUES with the movie & its content have NEVER ACTUALLY SEEN THE MOVIE, & are just responding in the TYPICAL LEFTIST “knee-jerk fashion” to anything that the left has deemed “RACIST”!!!
    It’s a crying shame that Disney fell into the “LEFTIST TRAP” & succumbed to the “opinions” of the FEW that “claim” the movie was “Racist” & therefore the ride that contained CARTOON CHARACTERS from the movie must also be “Racist”!!!
    As was previously mentioned, “Academy Award winning James Baskett and Hattie McDaniel had no problems with it.” so I fail to understand how anyone else possibly could!!!

  14. save the movie . there are a lot of movies that are much worse , that no one is complaining about .what about free speech? there are a lot of( we the people )that are still in slaved in this life. they just call it a job!

  15. The stories Uncle Remus told were morality lessons. No matter their origin, they were and are valuable. To try to erase them is like trying to erase Shakespeare because, in his time, women weren’t allowed to be on stage. Uncle Remus was not himself a slave at the time of these stories, he only passed on the morality lessons, which were valuable to the children in the film. But heaven forbid we have any morality tales in today’s world!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.