‘Peter Pan’ to Replace ‘Pirates of the Caribbean’ at Disney

pirates of the caribbean ride fantasmic peter pan
Credit: Disney

Disney attractions come and go. It’s part of the evolution of Walt Disney World and Disneyland, falling in line with Walt Disney’s vision to recreate something alive, changing as the world around it also changes.

Popular attractions like the Pirates of the Caribbean ride at Disneyland, Space Mountain, and the Haunted Mansion at Walt Disney World, and many others have undergone several changes over the lengthy and storied history of Disney Parks.

Pirates of the Caribbean attraction

Credit: Disney

Although Walt Disney World is home to many spectacular, old-school Disney dark rides such as Pirates of the Caribbean at Magic Kingdom, Disneyland is the original, opened to the public in 1955.

Many of the popular rides and attractions that guests enjoy in their favorite Disney Park found their inception at Disneyland. In fact, you could argue that the most popular and well-known rides Disney has to offer first entertained guests to “The Happiest Place on Earth.”

Related: Exciting Changes Come to Disney’s Dining Reservation System

Although rides and attractions often change, so do shows and entertainment options. At Magic Kingdom at Walt Disney World, we’ve seen several different variations of nighttime spectaculars that wow crowds high above Cinderella Castle, and Disneyland is no different.

These experiences invoke emotion from guests who have spent their entire day “being part of the story.”

Through the use of beautiful soundtracks, dazzling fireworks, projection mapping, and even a little bit of magic, guests are typically treated to a high-flying, amazing spectacular full of popular Disney moments and characters like Captain Jack Sparrow, Peter Pan, Mickey Mouse, and Tinkerbell.

walt disney world resort florida fourth of july fireworks show cinderella castle

Credit: Disney

Currently running at Magic Kingdom, “Happily Ever After,” one of the most adored nighttime speculators to ever grace a Disney Park, recently made its way back to Walt Disney World Resort. While at Disneyland, guests are treated to the nostalgic undertaking that is Fantasmic!

Now, I know what you’re thinking, Fantasmic! Isn’t that at Disney World’s Hollywood Studios? Why, yes, it is!

Fantasmic! at Disneyland

Fantasmic! is a mesmerizing nighttime extravaganza that takes place at Disneyland, captivating guests of all ages with its magical storyline and stunning visual effects. This immersive show, brought to life on the Rivers of America in Disneyland Park, combines fireworks, water projections, live performances, and beloved Disney characters to create an unforgettable experience.

Fantasmic Fire

Credit: Disney and Canva

Fantasmic! weaves a captivating story where Mickey Mouse takes center stage as the Sorcerer’s Apprentice. As night falls, Mickey’s vivid imagination brings a variety of Disney tales to life, but soon everything spirals into chaos when the evil Maleficent, along with other infamous Disney villains, attempts to take control.

Against all odds, Mickey finds the strength to overcome the darkness and restore harmony, proving that the power of imagination can conquer any challenge.

Throughout Fantasmic!, guests are enthralled by the beloved Disney characters who make appearances during the show. From princesses like Ariel, Snow White, and Cinderella to classic heroes like Peter Pan and Aladdin, audiences are treated to a magical gathering of iconic Disney figures.

Of course, no Disney performance would be complete without Mickey Mouse himself, whose role as the Sorcerer’s Apprentice anchors the entire show.

Related: Fantasmic! Dining Packages at Walt Disney World

One of the highlights of Fantasmic! is its stunning visual effects, which transport guests into a world of imagination. The Rivers of America serve as a gigantic canvas, filled with water projections that bring Disney stories to life in vibrant colors and amazing detail.

From cascading waterfalls to dancing fountains to fiery battles, these projections create a mesmerizing backdrop for the show. Combined with dazzling fireworks, pyrotechnics, and captivating lighting, Fantasmic! truly immerses guests in a spectacle of magic and wonder.

Fantasmic! features a talented cast of performers who bring the show to life with their exceptional singing and dancing skills. The energetic choreography, coupled with powerful musical numbers, adds another layer of excitement and emotion to the overall experience.

From the thrilling sword fights to the graceful movements of the characters, every moment of the show is carefully choreographed to create a seamless blend of storytelling and entertainment.

Fantasmic at Walt Disney World with Steamboat Willie

Credit: Disney

For anyone who’s experienced Fantasmic!, they can attest that the show is an absolute must-do on your Disney vacation despite the massive crowds that it garners. For many, it’s impossible to hear the words “Some imagination, huh” without bursting into tears.

Although the show currently runs at both Disneyland and Hollywood Studios in Florida, there are some subtle differences. One particular scene in Disneyland’s version features the extremely popular Pirates of the Caribbean character, Captain Jack Sparrow, made famous by none other than Johnny Depp.

Pirates of the Caribbean the Ride

Before Depp came on the scene as the lovable, misfit pirate Captain Jack Sparrow, Pirates of the Caribbean was already in existence. In fact, the famed boat ride that initially pushed the boundaries of animatronics was the single source of inspiration for the successful film franchise that would follow.

Related: Of All the Pirates of the Caribbean Rides, Disney World’s is the Worst

Originating at Disneyland Resort, where Walt Disney and Disney Imagineer Legend Marc Davis were heavily involved with the creation of the Pirates of the Caribbean ride, the popular attraction would soon find its way over to Walt Disney World, Disneyland Paris, Tokyo Disneyland, and Shanghai Disneyland.

New Orleans Square pirates of the caribbean ride

Credit: Disney

Although the Pirates of the Caribbean ride has always been popular among fans, it was granted new attention after the success of the Pirates franchise. Amongst the “Yo Ho, Yo Ho’s” characters like Captain Jack Sparrow and Davy Jones were added to the standing attraction, and they became the source of the main story at Shanghai Disney Resort’s highly technological version of the popular attraction.

Changes Over the Years to the Pirates of the Caribbean Ride

Although the addition of Jack Sparrow and Davy Jones to the popular Disney ride is one of the more apparent changes made at the Pirates of the Caribbean attraction, there have been a few controversial ones in the last few years.

Related: Walt Disney Company Quietly Makes Changes to Pirates of the Caribbean Attraction, Guests Disappointed and Disgusted

One scene in particular that Disney changed was the auction process of a redheaded woman that Disney faithful loyally coined “The Redhead.” No longer to the cheers of “We Wants the Redhead” loudly proclaim through the ransacked Caribbean town. Instead, Redd is now a pirate captain of her own, a physical testament to the changing times of Disney and the world around their theme parks.

Disneyland to Change Another Pirate Feature

So, we’ve discussed Fantasmic! and the Pirates of the Caribbean ride. We’ve also talked to you about progressive change within Disney Parks. Chances are, you’ve put the puzzle pieces together and have come to the conclusion that the Pirates of the Caribbean section of Fantasmic! at Disneyland is being replaced!

pirates of the caribbean ride Fantasmic at Disney's Hollywood Studios

Credit: Disney

If you guessed, congratulations, you’re right. If you didn’t, I’m sorry to be the one who has to break the news to you. Disneyland’s Fantasmic!, which closed to guests in April 2023 after the Maleficent dragon caught on fire, will be back soon with some major changes.

Firstly, the Maleficient dragon will not return to the show, to the jeers of many, but secondly, we now know, thanks to Inside the Magic, that the popular Pirates of the Caribbean section of the show will not return.

Related: Disney to REPLACE Maleficent Dragon With LIVE Animal Alternative

Instead of Jack Sparrow, Davy Jones, and other popular characters from the famous franchise, an iconic scene from 1953’s Peter Pan will take its place.

The original scene from Peter Pan, which was replaced several years ago, is confirmed by multiple Disneyland sources and is expected to make its debut in place of Captain Jack once Fantasmic! returns on May 24, 2024.

Should We Read Between the Lines?

Of course, the removal of anything having to do with Pirates of the Caribbean is going to find itself under heavy scrutiny. As the world collectively holds its breath to find out if Johnny Depp will reprise the award-winning role of Jack Sparrow, there are some who could interpret this reduction of representation as a sign that all hope is lost.

jack sparrow pirates of the caribbean ride

Credit: Disney/ Canva

Related: Johnny Depp to Return to ‘Pirates of the Caribbean’ Under ONE Condition

Although I wouldn’t disagree that we shouldn’t get our hopes up regarding a return to Pirates by Depp, and despite the incredible popularity of the almost billion-dollar franchise that has been graced by the likes of Orlando Bloom, Keira Knightly, Bill Nighy, Ian McShane, Geoffry Rush, and Javier Bardem, there’s clearly no correlation between the future of Pirates and Fantasmic!

As Disney is safeguarding the show from future pyro incidents, that probably is a more realistic consideration compared to anyone suggesting that the future of Pirates of the Caribbean is finished. As long as the Pirates of the Caribbean ride remains a treasured attraction and Johnny Depp is breathing, fans will scatter to theatres to see Jack Sparrow once again.

Are you excited about the change ahead, or do you prefer for Disney to leave Fantasmic! as is? Let us know in the comments. 

About Michael Arnold

Michael is a father, husband, and an Army Veteran. Michael spends his weekends at Walt Disney World and Universal Orlando checking out new merchandise and food. Michael is a graduate of the University of Alabama and has an education background in Public Health. You can find Michael riding Pirates of the Caribbean over and over again or binge watching new Marvel and Star Wars content. Han shot first. Thor is the strongest Avenger. Roll Tide and Wash Your Hands!


  1. Why can’t Disney just admit they made a big mistake in judging someone? Do they think removing the ride will make people forget how they trashed Johnny Depp? They can’t hide, since the whole world already knows what they did. This company is going under sooner or later. What a bunch of dopes.

  2. Judge and cancel johnny although he was cleared? But allow Will Smith who assaulted a peer on national television? Disgraceful.

  3. Pirates have been an icon ride to get rid of that for pan is a disgrace

    • I am forever disgusted with Disney’s treatment and lack of apology to Johnny Depp. So glad to see I’m not the only one. I hope they fail as they have failed us.

      • Dorothy Kay McDonald

        It’s ABOUT TIME! Shouldn’t be teaching children thriving is honorable, it’s down right disgusting and anyone who steals from another well…..let’s just leave that right there. Come on PAN and Tinker bell!!!! Wahoooooo!

      • He said, “Let’s drown her before we burn her!!! I will f—ck her burnt corpse afterwards to make sure she’s dead.”

        “Hopefully that c—t‘s rotting corpse is decomposing in the f—–g trunk of a Honda Civic!!”

        So… she’s a horrible person, but there was a lot going on there with him as well.

  4. Who makes these decisions???? Peter Pan can nit be pirate of the Caribbean, he does not fit the description of the character. This has to stop, if you keep changing things because some weak people can’t view what was made then Disney will lose patrons because of it.

  5. So let’s replace a ride theme over an allegation of an actor that just happened to be connected to the ride and replace it with a character who kidnaps boys at night.

  6. Pathetic sensationalistic header! You falsely mislead readers to think that a Peter Pan ride is replacing the Pirates of The Caribbean!
    Typical media!

  7. Well now I have even less a reason to go to that overpriced cess pool of misguided greed…it’s amusing to watch a once thriving company implode!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.