When two cinematic giants go head-to-head, it’s always fascinating to see how they fare against each other. On November 22, Universal’s highly anticipated adaptation of the hit Broadway musical Wicked premiered, closely followed by Disney’s Moana 2 on November 27. These two films were poised for box-office success, but their releases sparked debates over which film truly captured the hearts and minds of audiences.
The results reveal a tale of contrasts—blockbuster earnings, audience reactions, and critical reception—that illustrate a complex picture of victory.
Wicked: A Resounding Success with Fans
Even before its theatrical debut, Wicked was destined to be a cultural phenomenon. The film, starring Ariana Grande as Glinda and Cynthia Erivo as Elphaba, transported audiences to the land of Oz with dazzling visuals, iconic music, and a heartfelt story of friendship and identity. Fans were drawn to the lush world-building and the powerful performances by its cast, including Jonathan Bailey and Jeff Goldblum, whose portrayals added layers of depth to the narrative.
The film’s success wasn’t solely measured by numbers—though its box-office earnings of over $450 million in just a few weeks are undeniably impressive.
Related: Wicked’ Fan Sues Mattel for Disturbing Mix-Up with Pornographic Site
What truly set Wicked apart was its emotional resonance with viewers. Social media platforms were flooded with viral moments: fans dancing to “What Is This Feeling?”, heartfelt reactions to “Defying Gravity,” and endless praise for the film’s visuals and character dynamics. Critics applauded Wicked for staying true to its Broadway roots while delivering a cinematic experience worthy of the big screen.
Additionally, Wicked achieved remarkable critical acclaim. With an 88% critics’ score and a 95% audience score, the film’s reception highlighted its wide-reaching appeal. Many fans admitted to watching the film multiple times, and theaters reported repeat viewings as audiences were eager to immerse themselves in its spellbinding magic again and again.
Related: Pay Controversy Sparks Concerns for Future of ‘Wicked 2’: Universal Issues Urgent Statement
Moana 2: A Sequel with Mixed Results
Disney’s Moana 2 entered the ring with high expectations. Initially intended as a Disney+ series, the project’s evolution into a full-length feature film signaled Disney’s confidence in its potential. Starring returning voice actress Auli’i Cravalho as Moana, the sequel continued the Polynesian princess’s journey, blending new adventures with familiar themes of self-discovery and cultural heritage.
While Moana 2 dominated the Thanksgiving box office, grossing over $680 million globally within three weeks, its success came with notable caveats. Critics and audiences alike pointed out significant flaws that prevented the sequel from fully living up to the legacy of the original. The film’s 62% critics’ score contrasted sharply with its 88% audience score, highlighting a divide between professional reviewers and fans.
One major criticism revolved around the film’s structure. As a repurposed Disney+ series, Moana 2 often felt disjointed, with episodes stitched together to create a feature-length narrative. This lack of cohesion left some viewers feeling disconnected from the story. Additionally, the music—a standout feature of the first film—was perceived as less memorable this time around. The absence of Lin-Manuel Miranda, who penned the original’s beloved soundtrack, was keenly felt, and fans noted that the new songs didn’t evoke the same emotional depth.
The sequel’s storyline also came under scrutiny. Audiences described it as less original and impactful compared to Moana’s initial journey, with some expressing disappointment in its more formulaic approach. While it still retained elements of charm and adventure, the film struggled to capture the magic that made the original an instant classic.
Who Won the Battle?
If the competition is judged purely by box-office numbers, Moana 2 is the clear winner. Its record-breaking Thanksgiving debut and continued dominance in theaters underscore Disney’s ability to draw massive audiences. However, when the conversation shifts to audience enjoyment, Wicked emerges victorious. The overwhelmingly positive reactions, critical acclaim, and enduring cultural impact of the film solidify its status as a triumph for Universal.
Ultimately, both films will leave lasting impressions. Wicked has set a new benchmark for Broadway-to-film adaptations, while Moana 2’s financial success guarantees that Disney will continue exploring the beloved character’s story.
Have you seen Wicked and Moana 2 in theaters? Which one did you like best? Share your thoughts in the comments!
