“Plus-Size” Ariel in ‘The Little Mermaid’ Musical Ignites Controversy Among Disney Fans

Yesterday, Walt Disney World offered fans an exciting first glimpse of the revived The Little Mermaid – A Musical Adventure at Disney’s Hollywood Studios. The preview showcased new puppets, props, scenery, effects, and songs, giving audiences a sneak peek of what’s to come when the beloved show makes its return. The video highlighted the meticulous craftsmanship behind the updated design elements, hinting at a fresh take on the classic Disney story.

A Fresh Revival Receives Backlash

While many fans expressed enthusiasm over the show’s reimagined aspects, some comments beneath the preview video sparked controversy, particularly around the performance of the show’s lead, Ariel. Several users directed criticism at the actress playing the iconic mermaid, with some making disparaging remarks about her appearance. One comment stated:

“And a fat mermaid? We get that being overweight is the result of overeating and lack of exercise, and a mermaid eats fish and seaweed and does nothing but swim their entire life.” Another user joked, “She doesn’t look little.”

The most discussed point of contention revolved around the design of the tail puppet, which some felt was unflattering for the performer. Critics voiced concerns that the puppet detracted from the visual appeal of the performance. This critique prompted a broader conversation about body image and the treatment of performers in the entertainment industry, where appearance is often heavily scrutinized. However, many fans came to the defense of the performer, stressing the importance of inclusivity and diversity in casting, while also celebrating the show’s revival.

and a fat mermaid? we get that being overweight is the result of over eating and lack of exercise, and a mermaid eats fish and seaweed and does nothing but swim their entire life

— Gestalt (@___Gestalt) May 24, 2025

Will This Show Flop?

In addition to addressing the mixed reception, the revived The Little Mermaid show brings a wealth of new creative elements. The puppetry upgrades are expected to enhance the storytelling experience, while the revamped musical score will introduce modern twists on familiar tunes. New songs will add a fresh layer to the show’s soundtrack, offering audiences an updated musical journey that aims to captivate both old fans and newcomers alike.

Despite the negative feedback from some viewers, the overall response to the sneak peek has been overwhelmingly positive. Many are excited about the technological innovations and artistic enhancements being incorporated into the show. Fans are particularly eager to see how the iconic moments from The Little Mermaid will be reinterpreted with the new elements.

As the opening date approaches, Disney is likely to continue receiving feedback from guests, with many hoping that the revival will spark larger conversations about representation in theme park performances and the entertainment industry as a whole.

The revival of The Little Mermaid – A Musical Adventure promises to offer a fresh, exciting version of the beloved Disney classic. While the production’s design elements and casting choices may continue to stir public conversation, the show is poised to offer a modernized, enchanting experience that enhances Disney’s tradition of live performances at its theme parks. It remains to be seen whether this updated version will successfully resonate with audiences and live up to its magical legacy.