Is a Muppets Version of Oh, Mary! Coming? Cole Escola’s Casting Suggestion Sparks Interest
In an entertaining moment on Amy Poehler’s Good Hang podcast, Tony-winner Cole Escola shared a playful take on the potential film adaptation of Oh, Mary!, the hit Broadway comedy. While not confirming any details about a future film project, Escolaβs lighthearted comments have sparked a wave of excitement among theater fans and movie lovers alike.

Miss Piggy Eyed for Leading Role In Broadway Show
The standout moment came when the conversation turned to casting, with Escola suggesting an unconventional choice for the role of Mary Todd Lincoln. Rather than selecting a traditional actress for the part, Escola humorously proposed that Miss Piggy, the iconic Muppet, take on the lead role.
βActually, cut this because Iβm talking to Disney tomorrow,β Escola joked, hinting at a potential discussion about this idea with the company behind the Muppets. Miss Piggy, known for her sassy attitude and iconic performance skills, would be a perfect choice for this role, which has taken Broadway by storm.
Poehler, known for her quick wit, played along, responding, βI hope they have good lawyers because those Muppets donβt know what theyβre signing.β
An Exciting Possibility
While no official news has been announced about a Oh, Mary! movie adaptation, Escolaβs suggestion adds an amusing twist to the ongoing conversations around the showβs future. The idea of blending the sharp humor of the play with the beloved charm of the Muppets has captured fans’ imaginations and opened up a world of possibilities for future adaptations.
For now, fans are left to wonder if Miss Piggy will one day take on the role of Mary Todd Lincoln, but Escolaβs comments have definitely added an extra layer of intrigue to the idea of a Oh, Mary! film. If this did come into fruition, it would certainly become an iconic moment for Broadway fans as well as fans of The Muppets.
What do you think about this potential casting? Let us know in the comments below!