When it comes to beloved Disney characters, few can rival Captain Jack Sparrow from Pirates of the Caribbean. Johnny Depp’s offbeat and captivating portrayal of the swashbuckling antihero first charmed audiences in The Curse of the Black Pearl (2003).
What started as a risky bet for Disney—a movie based on a theme park ride—turned into a global sensation, thanks largely to Depp’s performance. Over the course of five films, Captain Jack became the heart and soul of the franchise, with his drunken swagger, sharp wit, and surprising bursts of heroism keeping audiences hooked.
But after Dead Men Tell No Tales (2017), the tides seemed to turn against Captain Jack. Depp became embroiled in highly publicized legal disputes with his ex-wife, Amber Heard, which led Disney to sever ties with the actor. During his defamation trial, Depp made headlines by declaring he wouldn’t return to the franchise, even for “hundreds of millions of dollars.” For fans, this felt like the end of an era, as the idea of a Pirates of the Caribbean movie without Captain Jack seemed unthinkable.
Fast forward to today, and there’s a glimmer of hope for fans longing to see their favorite pirate back on the big screen. Following Depp’s courtroom victory in 2022, public support for the actor has surged. Rumors have begun to swirl that Disney is rethinking the future of the Pirates franchise.
Insiders claim that the studio is working on multiple concepts for Pirates of the Caribbean 6, with one version reportedly including Depp’s return as Captain Jack. While no official offer has been made, industry sources suggest that “nothing is off the table.”
Fans have made it clear that they want Captain Jack back. For many, Depp’s portrayal is irreplaceable, with his humor, charm, and unpredictability forming the backbone of the franchise. Efforts to reboot the series without him have failed to generate the same level of excitement, leaving Disney at a crossroads. Can the Pirates of the Caribbean franchise truly succeed without its most iconic character?
For now, the future remains uncertain, but the possibility of Depp’s return has reignited hope among fans. Whether he chooses to don the pirate hat again is yet to be seen, but one thing is certain: Captain Jack Sparrow’s legacy continues to inspire waves of enthusiasm.
This thing is that Johnny Depp will ALWAYS play a key role in pirates. He has been in every single one for a reason… The last one had issues due to the amber heard situation. Depp said he wouldn’t come back and I can’t say I blame him… Amber heard ruined his Disney career… There is a reason Johnny Depp is getting attention for 6, he deserves the role… He is the main character always and forever. No one can replace him. If a prequel was to happen it would HAVE to be about Johnny’s character l. So yeah this movie will not do well on the box office BECAUSE of Johnny Depp not being Jack… The Publix knowing things.. if they make a 6 it will be the last one due to how money they are gonna freaking lose. So Disney truly has no choice but to beg for Johnny back
To put it simply, no Depp, no Pirates for me! And I know my nieces feel the same way… Johnny Depp IS Pirates of the Caribbean! Without him, it’s nothing. Captain Jack Sparrow breaths life into the project! Disney needs to wake up and look at the money they have made! Who made that money for them?
A
No Johnny Depp no pirates. He is the reason for Disneys success with the Pirates of the Caribbean. Disney should be groveling at Johnny Depp’s feet. If it wasn’t for him there would be no 3,4,or5. So Disney wake up and smell the coffee and get your heads out of your bum.
Not a big supporter of woke disney
I agree 100% and I’m am out used to be a huge Rodney fan… we go out at least went every year done we have been married 35 years, took my grand daughter got the food time last year… but till if things change or small plans may have to visit Universal Studio…
I agree 100% and I’m am out used to be a huge Disney fan… we go there at least, well went every year since we have been married, 35 years ago. We took my grand daughter for her time last year… but till things change or future plans may have to visit Universal Studio…
I will say that Johnny Depp is the only one that should play Jack. He made the other films fantastic. I have watched all of the movies several times. I enjoy them each time. I really don’t see anyone else taking his place. .
Disney swallow your pride. Apologize for being judgmental and move forward with Depp. Pirates is Johnny Depp and you owe it to him
I agree his marriage shouldn’t of played a roll in his acting that was a privet matter put Johnny back on the payroll give him what he wants Disney definitely will lose a lot of money no one going to buy tickets his fans wants him back in 6
If Johnny Depp is not in the movie I will not watch or buy the movie
I am also thinking of boycotting all Disney products.
The Disney company treated Johnny very unfairly when he was accused of battery against Amber Heard, they fired him before the end of the trial! They determened his guilt.
You simply can not make the movie with out Mr.Depp. it
will be a box office flop.
Sincerly
KAREN Drouillard.
Johnny Debb IS THE Pirate of the Caribbean!! There’s no one else that can (or should) step into those boots!!!
I grew up 80 miles from Disney world and LOVE everything Disney!! You’ve made a judgement on an induvidual without waiting for the true story!! I’m disappointment that Disney would be so judgemental.
I agree, Johnny Depp as Captain Jack Sparrow is the only solution that I see. Johnny is the Pirates franchise cash cow – $4.5 Billion to be exact, yet that only includes box office gross. Disney never should have did what they did to him. They became judge, jury and executioner to a man that is loved by millions of people worldwide.
#NoDeppNoPirates
Sorry, that should have said “to an INNOCENT man…”
The only one that could play Jack Sporrow right was Robin Williams & he’s not available anymore.
Can’t even believe you said that. Ridiculous. Peter Pan maybe, but not an even a close second for Sparrow.
Please don’t penalise the children and adults that know only Johnny Depp as Captain Jack Sparrow because some woman got vindictive and took him to court probably looking for a bigger settlement while also trying to smear his name in Hollywood. Any good actor can play a character, but it takes an actor with heart and soul for the character to bring the character to life. Johnny Depp has taken the time to take the Captain to visit children in hospitals all around the world. In my opinion, no other actor can do the character justice in the movies.
If Disney is planning on making Pirates 6, Johnny Depp as Captain Jack Sparrow should definitely be in the movie. There’s no one else that can replace Johnny Depp! Please bring Johnny back, whatever it takes. If they decide on making Pirates 6 without Captain Jack, I will not be interested in watching the movie.
Wake up Disney executives, Pirates 6 will definitely put $$$$$ in your bank accounts, Fans will love you for making a positive decision. As for a female pirate roll, are you kidding me? Johnny Drop deserves that honor.