Disney’s Snow White remake may be in trouble.
Related: New: Live-Action ‘Tangled’ Confirmed, Who Is Playing Rapunzel?
Disney’s recent live-action adaptation of Snow White has been met with considerable backlash. The official trailer amassed over 700,000 dislikes on YouTube shortly after its release, showcasing a staggering thumbs-up ratio of only 29,000 likes. With a total view count of 5.8 million, it became evident that approximately 87% of those who reacted to the trailer expressed negativity. Such a response is notable even for a large production, especially considering the anticipation surrounding this film.
Insights into this level of discontent can be gleaned by comparing it to other Disney trailers. Previous live-action adaptations have seen similar patterns of criticism; however, none have commanded such a significant disparity in reactions within such a short period. The trailers for both The Lion King and Mulan received mixed reactions, but neither reached the quick accumulation of dislikes that Snow White has achieved just over a week after its premiere.
Related: Guests Argue for Compensation After Biohazard Incident at Disneyland
Much of the conversation surrounding the live-action Snow White has centered on Rachel Zegler, the actress selected to portray the titular character. Zegler gained recognition from her roles in West Side Story and The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes. However, her casting as Snow White was marred by controversial comments she made regarding both the original animated film and her ner interpretation of the character.
Zegler’s remarks implied that her representation of Snow White would diverge from the damsel-in-distress archetype, which some fans embraced. However, others found her dismissive attitude towards the original film unsettling. She described the classic version as outdated, suggesting that her portrayal would be a significant modernization. This shift in tone, combined with her joking about the absence of a prince in the remake, alienated a portion of the fanbase that holds a deep affection for the traditional narrative.
The mixed reception to Zegler’s comments exemplifies how fans can quickly turn on an actor when they feel the original material is being disrespected, revealing a complex layer of loyalty to nostalgia in reimaginings.
Fan expectations also play a significant role in how the trailer has been received. Many have a preconceived notion of what they want from a Snow White adaptation, which includes the timeless elements of romance and enchantment. As the film seeks to present a fresh narrative perspective, it could potentially alienate viewers who are not ready for a departure from familiar storytelling styles.
The challenge of meeting audience expectations while introducing modern themes is one that many filmmakers face, especially in adaptations of well-loved classics.
Disney’s journey with live-action remakes has been nothing short of tumultuous. Previous remakes, including The Little Mermaid and Aladdin, faced significant controversies that often centered around casting choices, story alterations, and the balance between homage and innovation. While The Little Mermaid ultimately found success at the box office, it too sparked debates about race and representation, particularly concerning actress Halle Bailey.
