The 1990s marked a golden era for Disney Animation, delivering timeless classics like Beauty and the Beast (1991), Aladdin (1992), and The Lion King (1994). Amid these cinematic triumphs came the 1996 release of The Hunchback of Notre Dame, a visually stunning and narratively daring adaptation of Victor Hugo’s iconic novel.
While praised by critics for its bold themes and memorable music, the film often stood in the shadows of its more commercially successful counterparts — until now. After nearly three decades, this Disney gem is finally receiving its due recognition.
Related: Disney’s ‘Hunchback of Notre Dame’ Fan Theory CONFIRMED
A Dark Tale Earns a Certified Fresh Rating
Despite its hauntingly beautiful animation and Alan Menken’s unforgettable score, The Hunchback of Notre Dame often flew under the radar, partly because of its mature and unsettling subject matter. The story follows Quasimodo, a bell ringer confined to the Notre Dame Cathedral by his cruel guardian, Judge Claude Frollo.
Quasimodo’s journey to self-discovery and his friendship with the compassionate Esmeralda captivated audiences but also raised eyebrows for its dark themes—including lust, power, and religious corruption.
Now, nearly 30 years later, the film has achieved a significant milestone. Rotten Tomatoes recently revisited and aggregated 50 archival reviews from the film’s 1996 release, awarding it a “Certified Fresh” rating of 80%.
Esteemed critics like Roger Ebert hailed it as “a high point in the renaissance of Disney animation,” while Gene Siskel celebrated its “effective songs” and “tasteful bits of humor.”
Michael Wilmington of the Chicago Tribune acknowledged the film’s intensity, calling it one of Disney’s most emotionally resonant works for adults.
Except for Toy Story, Disney’s hasn’t really made a first-class scary movie — on the level of Dumbo, Bambi or Pinocchio — during its recent renaissance. The Hunchback of Notre Dame comes close, ringing the bells for adults if not their kids.
Related: Did Disney’s Most Disturbing Song Get a Movie Canceled?
The Canceled Live-Action Remake
In recent years, Disney has embraced the trend of remaking animated classics into live-action blockbusters. From The Jungle Book (2016) to The Little Mermaid (2023), these remakes have often reintroduced beloved stories to new generations while sparking debates among fans.
In 2019, Disney announced plans for a live-action adaptation of The Hunchback of Notre Dame, igniting excitement among fans of the original film. Alan Menken and Stephen Schwartz, the dynamic duo behind the original score, were set to return, promising a musical experience faithful to its predecessor.
Adding to the buzz, Frozen (2013) star Josh Gad signed on as a producer and was rumored to be considering the role of Quasimodo. Fans eagerly speculated about casting choices and the possibility of revisiting the film’s most iconic moments, including the powerful song “Out There” and the chilling “Hellfire.”
However, by 2023, news broke that the project had been shelved. Alan Menken himself confirmed the disappointing update, citing the story’s inherent darkness as a significant hurdle.
“You can’t have Hunchback without ‘Hellfire,’ but it’s just not something a lot of parents today would want their kids listening to,” Menken explained. The song, sung by Judge Frollo, explores themes of forbidden desire and damnation, which were already controversial in the animated film. Translating such elements to a live-action format posed challenges that Disney ultimately deemed insurmountable.
Related: Why Did Disney Cancel Its Live-Action ‘Hunchback of Notre Dame’?
Another obstacle was the film’s depiction of sensitive topics like racial prejudice and abuse of power. While these themes were integral to the original narrative, their inclusion in a modern live-action remake raised concerns about audience reception and marketability. The decision to cancel the project left fans disappointed, but underscored the complexities of adapting such a nuanced story for contemporary audiences.
A Missed Opportunity?
Though the cancellation of the live-action remake disappointed many, it’s clear that Disney’s original animated film stands as a testament to the studio’s willingness to push creative boundaries. While modern audiences may never see a reimagined version of Quasimodo’s tale on the big screen, the 1996 film remains a powerful reminder of the risks Disney took during its Renaissance era.
As fans celebrate the movie’s recent milestone, it’s worth revisiting the story that dared to delve into the shadows of humanity while offering a message of hope and acceptance. Whether you’re a long-time admirer or a newcomer, The Hunchback of Notre Dame invites us all to step out of the bell tower and embrace the world “Out There.”
What are your thoughts on the film’s legacy and the canceled remake? Let us know in the comments below!
