Disney FoodiesNews

Guest almost vomits after trying ‘most disgusting’ food item at Walt Disney World! Who thought this was a good idea?

When you visit Walt Disney World, every single day can feel like a celebration. It’s one of the things we love about the Most Magical Place on Earth.

This is true whether you visit on New Year’s Eve, your birthday, Independence Day, your anniversary, Thanksgiving, Christmas or some random Tuesday. So when it came to the 50th anniversary celebration at the parks, we knew the party was going to be over the top–fanfare, decorations, surprises around every corner, new attractions, a look back at old attractions, and of course, new things to eat and drink!

Mr. Toad’s Wild Ride sign at Walt Disney World, showcasing a lively illustration of Mr. Toad above the ride’s name—an inviting sight that promises classic Disney whimsy and adventure for park guests.

RELATED: A new 50th anniversary cocktail has us rethinking our love for Ariel and for drinking

But nothing could have prepared Guests for the “treat” that Disney’s chefs created in celebration of a beloved attraction from days gone by at Disney World. It’s been hailed “the worst thing ever” from Walt Disney World’s 50th anniversary Foodie Guide.

Specialty desserts and entrees inspired by The Little Mermaid take center stage at Magic Kingdom, displayed next to the Walt Disney World Foodie Guide’s 50th Anniversary Celebration banner. Fans can also raise a glass with the festive 50th anniversary drink, all part of the magical milestone celebration.

In a video that now has almost 400,000 likes, @BethanyVinton gags while she tries Mr. Toad’s Dome Cake for the first time. Oh, and she can almost swear it’s meat inside the “cake.”

A guest in a black cap covers her mouth in surprise near the food stalls at the theme park, possibly reacting to an unusual treat, with trees and fellow visitors visible in the lively background. A theme park guest in a black cap covers their mouth in surprise or disbelief, perhaps reacting to an unexpected flavor from one of the park’s unique food offerings during a sunny afternoon.

Poor Bethany; take a look at her video here:

@bethanyvinton

When you create Disney Parks Food Content and you don’t read the description before ordering a new 50th food item. 🤢 #disneyworld #disneyparks

♬ original sound – Bethany Vinton

@LilDisFan chunked hers after just one bite. And the photos of the cake aren’t so appealing either. Is that meatloaf??

https://twitter.com/LilDisFan/status/1444340829330493444

Mr. Toad at Walt Disney World, dressed in his signature red jacket, yellow vest, and blue bow tie, raises his hands by his head with a big smile, looking like he’s just smelled something funky on Main Street.

@WalrusCarp was super excited about trying both new eats inspired by Mr. Toad’s Wild Ride. Until Mr. Toad’s “gelatinous” ick ruined it for him. He says he gives it a “1.7.”

@walruscarp

Are the Mr. Toad Brat Burger and Dome Cake Terrible? Find out in this review! #mrtoad #disneyfoodie #disneyfood #wdwfood

♬ Sunny Day – Ted Fresco

Why would Disney do this? And who thought it was a good idea to create a cake that has the consistency and appearance of chopped meat? It’s not too often that Disney’s culinary experts strike out, but Mr. Toad’s Dome Cake was anything but a home run.

A dome-shaped treat featuring Mickey Mouse’s face, glazed in signature red and yellow, with a playful bite missing—showcasing iconic Disney magic that’s bound to delight any Walt Disney World fan.

The menu at Friar’s Nook at Magic Kingdom describes this version of Mr. Toad as a peanut cake with chocolate-peanut butter mousse and a salty caramel center. (It doesn’t make any mention of the floppy, “gelatinous” outer layer of the cake, however.)

We give Mr. Toad’s Dome Cake a 10/10 for appearance (until it jiggles). It’s super cute after all. But when it comes to a cake that looks and “feels” like chopped meat, well, we just can’t go along with that. We’ll give it a 1/10, and the 1 is simply because it’s Disney.

A zany Disney cartoon character with spiral eyes, a beaming grin, and a playful blue bow tie pops against a bright green backdrop—capturing the fun and quirky vibe of Walt Disney World food adventures.

Have you tried Mr. Toad’s Dome Cake? Let us know what you thought!

 

Becky Burkett

Becky's from the Lone Star State and has been writing since she was 10 and encountered her first Disney Park when she was 11. It was love at first Main Street Electrical Parade. Joy is blank lined journals, 0.7 mm pens, and all things Walt, Woody and Buzz, PIXAR, Imagineering, Sleeping Beauty (make it blue!), Disney Parks history and EPCOT. At Disney World, you'll find her croonin' with the birdies at the Enchanted Tiki Room or hangin' with Woody and the gang at Toy Story Land. If you can dream, you really can do it!

Related Articles