NewsParks

Controversy Surrounds Theme Park in Utah That Picks Up On Lost Disney Concept

Revival of Disney’s America Concept

In the early 1990s, Disney’s ambition to expand its theme park portfolio brought forth a groundbreaking concept known as Disney’s America. Proposed by then-CEO Michael Eisner, this ambitious project aimed to create a park dedicated to American history, situated just outside Washington, D.C.

Disney's Mickey Mouse in front of the United States American Flag
Credit: Canva, Disney

The plan included attractions and replicas of significant historical sites. However, this idea quickly faced fierce backlash from local residents and historians, who feared that the park would simplify and commercialize serious historical events.

Decades later, the spirit of Disney’s America resurfaces through the ambitious Liberty Village project located in Southern Utah. This new development intends to recreate 21 buildings from America’s colonial past, such as Independence Hall and Monticello. Thus, the project is similar to Disney’s long-shelved idea, aiming to provide educational and immersive experiences for guests while reflecting on the nation’s history.

The historical significance of this project cannot be ignored. Liberty Village attempts to entertain and educate visitors about America’s foundational heritage. As the park’s concept reflects the original Disney’s America vision, it also embodies the complexities of presenting history in an accessible format.

Aerial view of a park with winding paths, buildings, and water features on the left. On the right, an illustration of a busy dock with a crowd boarding a riverboat near a large, ornate building under a colorful sky.
Disney’s America concept art. Credit: Disney

Community Response and Controversy

As Liberty Village breaks ground, it faces substantial community resistance and controversy. Residents remain skeptical, raising concerns about how the park could distort historical narratives. Like the original site for Disney’s America, many community members worry that the theme park may prioritize entertainment over substantial historical representation.

These concerns are compounded by prominent but controversial figures like Lex Howard, CEO of Balance of Nature, who leads the Liberty Village initiative. His association with questionable business practices has raised eyebrows, making some community members uneasy about the project’s intentions.

Two people in 18th-century attire, one reading from a book and the other standing, engage with a group of children seated outdoors. A large document is displayed. Trees and buildings are in the background.
Credit: Liberty Village

Additionally, former Fox News host Glenn Beck and right-wing figure Dinesh D’Souza have become vocal advocates for Liberty Village, drawing attention to its polarizing support. Historians and local activists have expressed unease over these associations, fearing that the project might overlook the nuances and complexities inherent in American history.

The discontent surrounding Liberty Village is strikingly similar to the public’s reaction to Disney’s America, suggesting a repeating pattern of opposition to interpretive historical representations in entertainment settings.

Financial Aspects of Liberty Village

Financially, Liberty Village has made some strides, having secured approximately $30 million in funding since the project’s inception. However, significant hurdles remain, primarily the need for additional financial support from local municipalities and the state of Utah. Given the ambitious nature of bringing such a historical concept to life, the project’s economic viability has crucial implications for its development.

Mickey Mouse in a red blazer, smiling and holding a megaphone featuring the American flag design, with abstract red stripes in the background. This image is from one of Disney's war films, patriotic
Credit: Disney, Canva

Planners have formally requested around $3 million more in funding from the Utah state government, signaling desperation for financial backing to push the project forward. Many question if this project can sustain itself long-term, especially given the earlier failures of Disney’s America, which was halted due to similar financial uncertainties. Therefore, the project’s ability to secure additional funding may determine its progress, overall success, and longevity.

Political Support and Legislative Actions

Despite the brewing controversy, political support for Liberty Village appears steadfast. The Utah House of Representatives is already advancing proposals for additional financial funding for the project. This movement reflects a commitment to seeing the concept through despite opposition from various local factions.

Aerial view of a landscaped park with circular pathways, surrounded by trees and buildings, including a church and residential structures. The park features a central fountain and well-maintained lawns, with roads and parking areas nearby.

Opinions on the project remain divided. Some legislators highlight its potential to boost tourism in Southern Utah and redefine the region’s economic landscape. Others caution that the involvement of controversial figures and the project’s historical implications could hinder its acceptance in the broader community.

Liberty Village has the potential to establish a new precedent for how historical narratives are incorporated into theme park experiences across the nation. As developments unfold, it remains to be seen whether this revival of Disney’s America through Liberty Village will find its footing or face a fate similar to its forebear.

Rick Lye

Rick is an avid Disney fan. He first went to Disney World in 1986 with his parents and has been hooked ever since. Rick is married to another Disney fan and is in the process of turning his two children into fans as well. When he is not creating new Disney adventures, he loves to watch the New York Yankees and hang out with his dog, Buster. In the fall, you will catch him cheering for his beloved NY Giants.

Related Articles