Big Changes at Earl of Sandwich, Downtown Disney Marketplace

Big Changes at Earl of Sandwich, Downtown Disney Marketplace

Some things in life you just hope will not change, Earl’s was one of those for me. I had favorite sandwiches that are no longer offered, the prices have just increased, and the size of the sandwiches have decreased all at the same time.  No one else has the new menu online, so let me share that with you right now.

NEW Menu April 2014


The Earl’s Club-$6.49; The Original 1762®-$6.49;Chipotle Chicken Avocado-$6.49; Tuna Melt-$6.49; Pastrami Reuben-$6.49; The Full Montagu®-$6.49; Philly Cheesesteak-$6.49; Caprese-$6.49; Holiday Turkey-$6.49; Hawaiian BBQ-$6.49; Italian-$5.99; Avocado BLT-$5.99; BBQ Chicken-$5.99; Veggie-$5.99; Ham ‘N’ Swiss-$5.99.  JUST FOR KIDS: Pizza Sandwich $3.99; Turkey ‘n’ Swiss $3.99; Grilled Cheese $3.99.

HAND CRAFTED WRAPS-now all $6.49

Buffalo Chicken, Chicken Bacon Avocado, Baja Chicken, BBQ Ranch Chicken, Thai, Chicken Caesar, Spicy Tuna

FRESHLY TOSSED GREEN SALADS all $6.49 except House Salad is $5.49

Earl’s Cobb * (*gluten free); Baja Chicken; Chicken Caesar; Berry Chicken Almond*; Greek*; Asian; BBQ Chicken; Thai Chicken; House Salad*


Mac ‘n’ Cheese-$3.99; Coleslaw -$2.29; Potato Salad-$2.29; Pasta Salad-$2.29;


Small $3.49; Regular $4.49;


Cookies -$1.99; Cookie Bites $3.99; Brownies $2.29; Brownie Crème Sandwiches $2.49; Cupcakes $2.49; Strawberry Shortcake $2.99; Ice Cream Sandwiches $3.29.


Fountain Beverages-$2.99-3.49; Bottled Beverages $3.29; Earl Grey Lemonade-$2.99-3.49; Iced Tea $2.99-3.49; Sweet Tea $2.99-3.49; Coffees $2.29; Hot Teas $2.29; Hot Chocolate $2.29; Milk $2.29; Frozen Lemonade $3.99. Bottled beers and wines starting at $5.99.

SMOOTHIES- all $3.99

Chocolate Banana, Strawberry Banana, 3 Berry, Mocha Latte, Frozen Latte, Hawaiian

For a no obligation, FREE Quote with new bookings contact our sponsor Magical Vacation Planner by calling: 1(407)442-0289 Or for a free no obligation quote with new bookings you can fill out the form by Clicking HERE!

BREAKFAST served until 11 AM

(If you want sandwich made with bagel add 50 cents) Egg ‘n’ Cheddar-$3.99; Ham, egg ‘n’ Cheddar -$3.99; Ham ‘n’ Swiss $3.99; Bacon, Egg ‘n’ Cheddar $3.99; Breakfast BLT $3.99; Skinny Bagel Egg White Sandwiches $3.99. Oatmeal $2.49; Made-to-order Omelets served with half bagel and home-style potatoes: Veggie -$5.99; Ham ‘n’ Cheddar $5.99; Cheddar $4.99

So, what has changed in price? All hot sandwiches used to be $5.99, so the majority of the sandwiches went up 50 cents a sandwich. All Salad and Wraps also increased by 50 cents. Cole Slaw and Potato Salad went up 30 cents. The Kids sandwiches, soups, and Bakery items did not increase. Coffee increased 30 cents per cup; Earl Grey Lemonade increased $1.00-$1.49 per cup depending on size; Fountain soda increased $1.00 to $1.50 each; Hot Tea is up 30 cents per cup; Bottled beverages up 30 to 80 cents each; Iced Tea up $1.00 to $1.50 per cup, Hot Chocolate up 30 cents per cup, and Frozen Lemonade increased by $1.00 per cup.

Are there new items on the menu? Yes, Made-to-Order Omelets are an impressive addition to the Breakfast menu. They have also added the Skinny Bagel Egg White Sandwich to the before 11AM menu.  On the Hot Sandwiches Menu we gained some sandwiches which were introduced as a limited time item: Pastrami Reuben, Philly Cheesesteak, Avocado BLT, Veggie and BBQ Chicken.

What items are no longer available?  All American (Turkey, cheddar, cranberries, lettuce, tomato & ranch dressing), CannonBalls! ®(meatballs, mozzarella, Parmesan & marinara sauce), Caribbean Jerk Chicken (grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, banana peppers & spicy jerk sauce), Best BLT (Bacon, lettuce, tomato & seasoned mayonnaise).

I cannot give you measurements of the sandwiches, but they appear much smaller.  I have heard many people complaining about this so it is not just my opinion.  People are leaving hungry which is not common for the Earl’s of the past.  I ordered a new sandwich, and one that has been on the menu forever for comparison sake.  There was very little avocado, maybe two slices about 1/8” thick on the Avocado BLT and less than a full slice of a tomato on the sandwich.  So it is not just the size, but reduced amounts of items on the sandwiches.  I ordered the Original which is roast beef, cheddar and horseradish sauce.  I was sad to lift up that roll top to see what was inside.

Earl of Sandwich is such a staple for most people that they will probably pay the increased prices, but I believe the increase will keep away more people who are not on the Disney Dining Plan and have to pay cash for everything on the menu. When you just use dining credits you don’t notice the prices but the rest of us do. They do not offer Tables in Wonderland discounts but do give 10% off for Annual Passholders.  If you are a AAA member, show your card for a 15% discount. The sandwich was still enjoyable, I won’t argue with that, but it is less for more money, that is what I don’t like.

By Cassie

About Cassie

Cassie L. I am a lifelong Disney fan. I attended Walt Disney World in 1971, and was there during the opening week of EPCOT, and have visited the Disney Parks for than 30 times. I have had the privilege of visiting Disneyland as a child, and then again with my children. My family recently moved from the northeastern United States to the Walt Disney World area. I now have cast members in my family and enjoy hearing the magical stories at the end of a shift. I love visiting all of the parks and getting to try more Disney food and being able to share it with you to help you plan your own magical day at Disney.