Top 12 Desserts You Must Try at Walt Disney World

6. Peanut Butter and Jelly Milkshake – 50s Prime Time Café, Hollywood Studios

Yes, that’s right—a milkshake made of peanut butter and jelly blended with ice cream! When I first read it on the dessert menu at the 50s Prime Time Café at Hollywood Studios, I decided to pass on it. But my friend ordered it, and after tasting hers, I had to order my own! I’m not sure if it’s the milkshake by itself that’s so good, or if it’s enjoying the milkshake as an experience at the Prime Time Café that makes it so good. Either way, it’s one I’ll definitely order again! (Photo credit: Disney)