2. Olivia’s Café, Old Key West Resort
I love Olivia’s. It may be one of Disney’s best kept secrets (like they claim the Disney Vacation Club that surrounds it to be). Since it is at Old Key West Resort it is seldom visited or thought of like The Turf Club, other than by guests of the resort. And there are many loyal patrons of this restaurant, but it is still relatively easy to get a dining reservation if you are planning at less than 180 days. Olivia’s Café is open for 3 meals a day, and has a great menu inspired by the Keys. Banana Bread French Toast at Breakfast, Mallory Square Cobb Salad for lunch, or Southernmost Fried Chicken at Dinner—and of course Conch Fritters and Conch Chowder, you can’t go wrong.